* American blogger told: “I look forward to day when you pigs get your throats cut”
* Reuters confirms it has suspended an employee
CONTENTS
1. “I think it’s more than fair to say that Reuters has a big problem”
2. “Zionists up to mischief”
3. “A news agency that will not call a terrorist a terrorist”
4. Online petition to get Guy Goma a job at the BBC
5. “Reuters employee issues ‘Zionist pig’ death threat” (Yediot Ahronot, May 30, 2006)
6. “Reuters recruits 100 journalists” (Guardian, May 30, 2006)
7. “Petition launched to get Guy Goma a BBC job” (Daily Telegraph, May 30, 2006)
8. “The case of Reuters” (By Tom Gross, National Review, July 26, 2004)
Perhaps it is not surprising that The Guardian has now invited Bunglawala to contribute to its website.
“A NEWS AGENCY THAT WILL NOT CALL A TERRORIST A TERRORIST”
Reuters has also announced that it is in the process of hiring 100 journalists after three years of reorganization. The Guardian (article attached below) reports that “Reuters is also hiring special journalists to write about religion, terrorism, health and entertainment.”
It will be interesting to see how the new Reuters special journalists write about terrorism, since as I commented in “The case of Reuters,” Reuters is the “news agency that will not call a terrorist a terrorist.”
ONLINE PETITION TO GET GUY GOMA A JOB AT THE BBC
Included in the dispatch BBC slips up with taxi driver (& Rapper Jay-Z: Anti-Semitism not cool) (May 18, 2006), was a video and article on the man mistakenly interviewed live on the BBC.
Guy Goma, a graduate from the Congo, was mistaken for a leading internet expert as he waited to be interviewed for a job in the BBC’s IT department. Goma was also mistaken for a taxi driver by Reuters in the article included in that dispatch.
Goma, who has now gained near-celebrity status in Britain and beyond as a result of the BBC’s mishap, has become the focus of an online petition, launched to get him a job at the BBC, and stop him from being deported as it is thought he may have overstayed his visa. The petition and commentary, which can be found at www.guygoma.com, urges the BBC to give him the job he wanted, or, preferably, a better one. For more, see the Daily Telegraph article below.
-- Tom Gross
REUTERS IN THE PROCESS OF HIRING 100 JOURNALISTS
Reuters recruits 100 journalists
By Stephen Brook
The Guardian
May 30, 2006
media.guardian.co.uk/presspublishing/story/0,,1784142,00.html
Reuters, the international news and financial information company, is in the process of hiring 100 journalists after three years of cost cutting and reorganisation.
While the new hirings will boost the ranks of Reuters journalists to 2,400, this is still short of the 2,500 journalists who worked for Reuters in 2000.
“At a time when other media organisations shrink, we are expanding our global reach,” said David Schlesinger, the global managing editor and head of editorial operations. “First, we had to right our ship. Now the ship is righted, we can look to new markets.”
The company is hiring 21 political and general news journalists across the world and 12 new editors for its global picture desk, which is now run from Singapore following a reorganisation.
Reuters is also hiring special journalists to write about religion, terrorism, health and entertainment.
The company, founded by Paul Julius Reuter in London in 1851 to transmit stock market data from London to Paris, is also expanding its presence in several US cities, including Cincinnati.
To cover its financial services business, the company will recruit business journalists to report on the US treasury, equities, commodities and the energy industry.
Additional journalists are being hired to cover China and India. “This really is the China century,” Mr Schlesinger said. “We will now have 160 to 170 journalists in greater China. When I was Beijing bureau chief in 1990s, we had four people in Beijing, four people in Hong Kong and three people in Taiwan.”
The new staff will work across Reuters’ operations, including its news wire service, new media activities and its financial services operations, which generate the bulk of its revenues.
In recent years, the company has expanded its online operations to make its stories more widely available to the general public in addition to Reuters’ traditional clients – newspapers and other media groups.
The company is also expanding its coverage of sport, with three sport writers in the US and a sports writer in Beijing, as well as a sports editor in Singapore in preparation for the Beijing 2008 Olympics.
Reuters has made extensive preparations to cover the World Cup next month. The company will have 56 photographers in place for the tournament, plus 11 from Action Images, the London-based sports picture agency Reuters bought in September.
Forty journalists writing in four languages, 10 video staff and Reuters’ German bureaux will cover the sporting event.
Reuters has extensively reorganised its picture operations in time for the World Cup. “Five minutes after the action has happened on the field, we will have the picture on our website for our clients,” said Monique Villa, the managing director of Reuters Media, the division that covers picture operations and news wires.
Last month, Reuters released a first-quarter revenue statement that showed a 13% increase in turnover to £633m. Revenues rose by 4% (if currency fluctuations, disposals and acquisitions are excluded) beating analysts’ forecasts of a 2.5% increase in organic turnover. Ms Villa said Reuters Media’s growth was approaching double digits this year.
THE RIGHT GUY FOR THE JOB
Petition launched to get Guy Goma a BBC job
The Daily Telegraph
May 30, 2006
www.telegraph.co.uk/news/main.jhtml?xml=/news/2006/05/30/ugoma.xml&sSheet=/news/2006/05/30/ixnews.html
An online petition has been launched to get the man mistakenly interviewed on BBC News 24 a job at the corporation.
Guy Goma, a graduate from the Congo, was mistaken for a leading internet expert as he waited to be interviewed for a job in the BBC’s IT department.
He was thrust onto live TV and asked for his opinions on the Apple vs Apple court case, a subject he clearly knew little about.
Despite his bravery and perseverance in pressing ahead with the bizarre exchange, Mr Goma has since discovered that he has not got the data support cleanser post he had applied for.
Now the www.guygoma.com website has started an online campaign to get him a job at the BBC. The petition urges the corporation to give him the job he wanted, or, preferably, a better one
The mix-up which shot Mr Goma to fame occurred when a producer went to collect an expert from the wrong reception in BBC Television Centre in west London.
The producer asked for Guy Kewney, editor of Newswireless.net, who was supposed to be interviewed. After being pointed in Mr Goma’s direction by a receptionist, the producer – who had seen a photo of the real expert – checked: “Are you Guy Kewney?”
The economics and business studies graduate answered that he was, and was then whisked up to the studio, where his live ordeal began.
Mr Goma’s interview led to several TV appearances, including The Jonathan Ross Show and manning the phones for the Prince’s Trust broadcast.
He is also auctioning the lucky blue shirt he wore during the interview for Oxfam, at www.15minutesauction.com.
THE CASE OF REUTERS
The case of Reuters
A news agency that will not call a terrorist a terrorist
By Tom Gross
The National Review
July 26, 2004
www.nationalreview.com/issue/gross200407120846.asp
Many people still think of Reuters as the Rolls-Royce of news agencies. Just as the House of Morgan was once synonymous with good banking, Reuters has long been synonymous with good news-gathering. In 1940, there was even a Hollywood film about Paul Julius Reuter, the German-Jewish immigrant to London who as early as 1851 began transmitting stock-market quotes between London and Paris via the new Calais-Dover cable. (Two years earlier he had ingeniously used pigeons to fly stock prices between Aachen and Brussels.)
His agency quickly established a reputation in Europe for being the first to report scoops from abroad, such as news of Abraham Lincoln’s assassination. Today, almost every major news outlet in the world subscribes. Operating in 200 cities in 94 countries, Reuters produces text in 19 languages, as well as photos and television footage from around the world.
Though it may report in a largely neutral way on many issues, Reuters’s coverage of the Middle East is deeply flawed. It is symptomatic, for instance, that Reuters’s global head of news, Stephen Jukes, banned the use of the word “terrorist” to describe the perpetrators of the September 11 attacks. Even so, such is the aura still surrounding Reuters that news editors from Los Angeles to Auckland automatically assume that text, photos, and film footage provided by Reuters will be fair and objective. Reuters and Associated Press copy is simply inserted into many correspondents’ reports – even in papers such as the New York Times and Washington Post – without, it often seems, so much as a second thought given to its accuracy.
This has led to some misleading reporting from Iraq, and still worse coverage of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The newswires are much more influential in setting the news (and hence diplomatic) agenda of that struggle than most people realize.
“REUTERS SETS THE TONE AND SPIN IS EVERYTHING”
One veteran American newspaper correspondent in Jerusalem, eager to maintain anonymity so as not to jeopardize relations with his anti-Israel colleagues, points out that “whereas foreign correspondents still write features, they rarely cover the actual breaking news that dominates the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. In terms of written copy on the conflict, I would estimate that 50 percent of all reporting, and 90 percent of the attitude, is formed by these news agencies. The important thing about Reuters is that it sets the tone, and here spin is everything.”
“If, for example, a Reuters headline and introduction say that Israelis killed a Palestinian, instead of saying that a Palestinian gunman was killed as he opened fire on Israeli civilians, this inevitably leaves a different impression of who was attacking, and who defending.”
In a study last year, the media watchdog HonestReporting found that in “100 percent of headlines” when Reuters wrote about Israeli acts of violence, Israel was emphasized as the first word; also, an active voice was used, often without explaining that the “victim” may have been a gunman. A typical headline was: “Israeli Troops Shoot Dead Palestinian in W. Bank” (July 3, 2003). By contrast, when Palestinians attacked Israelis (almost always civilians), Reuters usually avoided naming the perpetrator. For example: “New West Bank Shooting Mars Truce” (July 1, 2003). In many cases, the headline was also couched in a passive voice.
Often it is a question of emphasis: Important and relevant information is actually contained in Reuters text, but buried deep down in the story. Many newspaper readers, however, never get beyond the headlines, and for space reasons many papers carry only the first few paragraphs of a report – often inserted into their own correspondents’ stories. When the TV networks run only brief headlines, or Reuters news ribbon at the foot of the screen, the full text is never shown.
Sometimes, Reuters presents unreliable information as though it were undoubtedly true. Most people are unlikely to notice this. For example, Reuters will note that “a doctor at the hospital said the injured Palestinian was unarmed” – when in fact the doctor couldn’t possibly have known this, since he wasn’t present at the gunfight. But because he is a doctor, Reuters is suggesting to readers that his word is necessarily authoritative. Yet, Reuters headlines and text are used unchanged by newspaper editors because they assume it is professional, balanced copy, which doesn’t need any further editing.
Reporters of course can’t be everywhere at once. The increased speed of the Internet and the demand for instant, 24-hour TV news coverage means that the world’s news outlets rely heavily on Reuters and the AP, which in turn rely on a network of local Palestinian “stringers.” Virtually all breaking news (and much of the non-breaking news) on CNN, the BBC, Fox, and other networks comes from these stringers.
PROVOKING THE WRATH OF ARAFAT’S SECURITY FORCES
Such stringers are hired for speed, to save money (there is no need to pay drivers and translators), and for their local knowledge. But in many cases, in hiring them, their connections to Arafat’s regime and Hamas count for more than their journalistic abilities. All too often the information they provide, and the supposed eyewitnesses they interview, are undependable. Yet, because of Reuters’s prestige, American and international news outlets simply take their copy as fact. Thus non-massacres become massacres; death tolls are exaggerated; and gunmen are written about as if they were civilians.
As Ehud Ya’ari, Israeli television’s foremost expert on Palestinian affairs, put it: “The vast majority of information of every type coming out of the area is being filtered through Palestinian eyes. Cameras are angled to show a tainted view of the Israeli army’s actions and never focus on Palestinian gunmen. Written reports focus on the Palestinian version of events. And even those Palestinians who don’t support the intifada dare not show or describe anything embarrassing to the Palestinian Authority, for fear they may provoke the wrath of Arafat’s security forces.”
One Palestinian journalist told me that “the worst the Israelis can do is take away our press cards. But if we irritate Arafat, or Hamas, you don’t know who might be waiting in your kitchen when you come home at night.”
Some of Reuters’s Palestinian stringers are honest and courageous. But, according to several ex-Reuters staffers, they feel the intimidating presence of Wafa Amr, Reuters’s “Senior Palestinian Correspondent.” Amr – who is a cousin of former Palestinian minister Nabil Amr, and whose father is said to be close to Arafat – had this title specially created for her (there is no “Senior Israeli Correspondent,” or the equivalent in any other Arab country) so that her close ties to the Palestinian Authority could be exploited.
As one former Reuters journalist put it: “She occupies this position in spite of lacking a basic command of English grammar. The information passed through her is controlled, orchestrated. Reuters would never allow Israeli government propaganda to be fed into its reports in this way. Indeed, stories exposing Israeli misdeeds are a favorite of Reuters. Amr has never had an expose on Arafat, or his Al-Aqsa Brigades terror group.”
But things may well be improving. Lately, with a new Jerusalem bureau chief, Reuters has taken some steps to ensure greater balance. For example, it no longer claims Hamas’s goal is merely “to set up an independent state in the West Bank and Gaza” (which it is not), but instead writes that Hamas is “sworn to Israel’s destruction” (which it is).
Reuters no longer carries the highly misleading “death tolls” at the end of each story that lumped together Palestinian civilians, gunmen, and suicide bombers. (Agence France-Presse continues to do this.) And, apparently, there are plans to relocate Wafa Amr by next year. Is it too much to hope that one day soon Reuters might actually call terrorism terrorism?
* Hillel Halkin on how The New York Times selectively reports the West Bank checkpoint issue
CONTENTS
1. Iranian foreign minister: “No such country as Israel”
2. Israel sends ground force into Gaza
3. Iran gives Hizbullah long-range missiles
4. British national arrested for assisting Hamas
5. The confiscated money went to Hamas after all
6. PFLP to join Hamas-led government
7. IDF stops suicide bomber en route to attack in Israel
8. Police search for attacker who stabbed boy in Jerusalem
9. Israeli set to join OECD body of industrialized nations
10. Polish chief rabbi assaulted as pope visits
11. Iraqi athletes killed for wearing tennis shorts
12. Islamist organizations in Kashmir warn women not to use cell phones
13. U.S. pop show victor attracts more votes than any President
14. “Tel Aviv within range of new Hezbollah rocket” (Ha’aretz, May 29, 2006)
15. “Israeli soldiers thwart suicide attack” (Associated Press, May 29, 2006)
16. “The purpose of checkpoints” (By Hillel Halkin, New York Sun, May 30, 2006)
As with past dispatches, I attach the following news items because the so-called mainstream media, from which the vast majority of opinion-formers and policy-makers obtain their news, have barely reported on them, if at all.
IRANIAN FOREIGN MINISTER: “NO SUCH COUNTRY AS ISRAEL”
“There is no such country” as Israel, Manouchehr Mottaki, the Iranian foreign minister, said yesterday. Mottaki was speaking at a ministerial meeting of the Nonaligned Movement held in the Malaysian city of Putrajaya. The Iranian foreign minister also declared that the United States was too tied down in Iraq and Afghanistan to be able to launch an attack on Iran.
ISRAEL SENDS GROUND FORCE INTO GAZA
In a pre-dawn raid this morning, Israel sent special forces ground troops deep into Gaza for the first time since it unilaterally withdrew from the territory last fall. The target was an Islamic Jihad Qassam rocket crew that was preparing to fire rockets into Israel from what used to be the Israeli settlement of Dugit. Since that time, Dugit has often been used as a base from which to launch rockets at Israeli towns and villages. The Israeli commandos waited for the Palestinian rocket crew to arrive and then tried to prevent them from launching Qassams. Three Jihadists were killed in the fierce gun battle that ensued. There were no injuries to the Israeli force, which left the Strip soon after the clash.
IRAN GIVES HIZBULLAH LONG-RANGE MISSILES
Iran has transferred to the Lebanon-based Hizbullah terrorist group much longer-range rockets capable of hitting Tel Aviv and even Beersheba in southern Israel, Israel’s leading defense journalist, Ze’ev Schiff, reports.
Schiff, writing in the daily Ha’aretz, says the new rockets are called the Zelzal-2; its earlier model was called the Zelzal-1. Another Iranian name for the rocket is Nazeat. The weapons have doubled Hizbullah’s effective range, to about 125 miles (200 kilometers), putting all of Israel’s major urban centers within striking distance. The new missiles carry a 1300-pound (600- kilogram) warhead.
The rockets were first seen in a military parade in Teheran on September 2005, the first such event following the election of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad as president. Six Shehab-3 surface-to-surface ballistic missiles were also on display. In response to slogans written on the Shehab-3 rockets, calling for “Death to Israel” and “Death to the U.S.,” the military attaches of France, Italy, Greece and Poland, invited to the event, left the VIP platform.
Hizbullah fired a barrage of shorter-range Katyusha rockets from Lebanon into northern Israel on Sunday. United Nations Security Council Resolution 1559 demands that all armed militias in Lebanon disarm.
BRITISH NATIONAL ARRESTED FOR ASSISTING HAMAS
The Israeli government announced yesterday that a British national, Iyaz Ali, was arrested in Israel by Israeli police three weeks ago, on May 10, after a tip-off from Israeli intelligence. Ali, who was born in Pakistan, is accused of transferring funds and assistance to Hamas institutions and operatives, in violation of Israeli law.
Ali is an activist in the UK-based Islamic Relief Worldwide (IRW), which was established in 1984 in the British city of Birmingham, and has a branch in Gaza. It has NGO status in the U.K.
In addition to incriminating files about financial payments to Hamas found on Ali’s computer, also found were photographs of swastikas superimposed on the Star of David, photographs of senior German Nazi officials, of Osama Bin Laden and Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, as well as many photographs of Hamas’ “military activities.”
Ali, 36, was released yesterday (Monday), with police restrictions placed on his movements within Israel. He will be deported from Israel in the coming days and will be barred from returning.
THE CONFISCATED MONEY WENT TO HAMAS AFTER ALL
Some 640,000 Euros confiscated from a Hamas official at the Rafah crossing earlier this month has been given to Hamas after all. Some of it will pay for a militia manned by Izaddin Al-Kassam terrorists.
The cash, the equivalent of $820,000, was discovered in the baggage of the Hamas spokesman, Sami Abu Zuhri, as he made his way into Gaza from Egypt. European Union inspectors confiscated the money, which was over 400 times more than the amount permitted to be imported without declaration.
Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas had ordered the money transferred to the prosecution offices of the PA, and demanded an investigation into the Hamas spokesman and his activities.
However, Abu Zuhri announced to the Palestinian Information Center, thought to be the main media outlet for Hamas, that the money went to “the correct party.” It is thought that Abu Zuhri’s reference to the “correct party” is a reference to Hamas operatives.
PFLP TO JOIN HAMAS-LED GOVERNMENT
Representatives of the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine (PFLP), one of the most extreme Palestinian terrorist groups, announced on Sunday that they had agreed to join the Hamas-led government. They also said they would be willing to participate in the new Hamas security force.
IDF STOPS SUICIDE BOMBER EN ROUTE TO ATTACK IN ISRAEL
Israeli security forces intercepted a suicide-bombing attempt on Sunday morning. Military sources said the two Palestinians were a suicide bomber and his driver who were on their way to carry out an attack in Israel. Their bag was found to contain a belt packed with explosives, which was then safely detonated by IDF explosives experts. (For more on this, please see the articles below, from the Associated Press, and the excellent commentary by Hillel Halkin criticizing The New York Times’s coverage of the checkpoint issue.)
POLICE SEARCH FOR ATTACKER WHO STABBED BOY IN JERUSALEM
Israeli police are continuing their search for the Arab man who stabbed a 14-year old Jewish boy in the back in Jerusalem on Saturday night. It was the second stabbing in two days. On Friday, a Palestinian stepped out of his car to ask an Israeli man for water and stabbed him in the neck when he turned his back.
ISRAEL SET TO JOIN OECD BODY OF INDUSTRIALIZED NATIONS
Israel expects to become a full member of the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), the prestigious world body of 30 industrialized countries. Over the last 10 years of negotiations, Israel faced a number of hurdles. Some member states objected to the Jewish State’s inclusion because of its conflict with the Palestinians.
Efforts to join the OECD were launched in 1996 under then-prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Full membership will automatically improve Israel’s credit rating, widen Israel’s exposure to international bidders and lure foreign investors. Israel will also benefit from exchanging information and data in the economic and social fields with leading industrialized nations.
Member states will vote on the expansion of the body from 30 to 40 members, with Russia, India, Brazil, China and Chile also expected to now become full members.
The Israeli economy grew at a record 6.6% in the first quarter of 2006 – far above early forecasts and the growth rate for all of 2005, which was 5.2%. The standard of living has risen by 9% in the last year. These positive trends are thought to be the direct result of the pro-market policies implemented by the previous Likud-led government under the finance ministry of Benjamin Netanyahu.
POLISH CHIEF RABBI ASSAULTED AS POPE VISITS
As an update to the previous dispatch about the pope’s trip to Poland, Matthias Goering Goes Kosher (& Film shows suffering of Jews Britain sent to Outback) (May 24, 2006), the pope’s visit to Auschwitz was reported very prominently in media throughout Europe yesterday, with it being the lead story in several papers in France, Spain, Italy and elsewhere.
However, most papers failed to report on the anti-Semitic attack on Poland’s chief rabbi, Michael Schudrich, in central Warsaw on Saturday, a day before Pope Benedict XVI visited the Auschwitz-Birkenau death camp.
Schudrich, who became chief rabbi of Warsaw in 2000 and of all of Poland in 2004, was attacked on the street by a man shouting “Poland is for Poles.” The assailant hit the rabbi and then sprayed him with what was believed to be pepper gas.
Both Polish Prime Minister Kazimierz Marcinkiewicz and President Lech Kaczynski called Schudrich following the incident and strongly condemned the attack. Presidential undersecretary of state Ewa Junczyk-Ziomecka said Poland would not tolerate anti-Semitism.
Schudrich, 50, an American, oversees the small remaining Jewish community in Poland. Schudrich linked the attack to what he said was a rise of intolerance connected to a new governing coalition that includes the League of Polish Families, a small extreme right-wing party with ideological ties to a prewar anti-Semitic party.
IRAQI ATHLETES KILLED FOR WEARING TENNIS SHORTS
An Iraqi tennis coach and two of his players were shot dead on Thursday in Baghdad because they were wearing shorts, Manham Kubba, secretary-general of the Iraqi Tennis Union, said Saturday, reporting the latest in a series of recent attacks attributed to Islamic extremists.
The triple-murder came only days after Islamic terrorists warned against dressing in shorts. Leaflets were distributed warning people in the mostly Sunni neighborhoods of Saidiyah and Ghazaliyah not to wear shorts “because it violates the principals of Islam,” police said
It was the second incident involving athletes in just over a week. Fifteen members of Iraq’s Olympic tae-kwan-doe team remain missing after being kidnapped west of Baghdad on May 17. A $100,000 ransom has been demanded.
ISLAMIST ORGANIZATIONS IN KASHMIR WARN WOMEN NOT TO USE CELL PHONES
Islamist organizations in Kashmir have issued pamphlets urging women to refrain from carrying mobile (cell) phones and warned them to stay away from public parks, according to the London-based, Saudi-owned daily al-Sharq al-Awsat.
The statement issued by the Islamic Jihad movement in Kashmir stated, “This is a warning to young women not to use mobile phones and stay away from public parks, and for fathers to look after their daughters. This is our final warning.”
Al-Sharq al-Awsat notes that another organization based in Kashmir, Badr, had issued a similar threat two weeks ago. The paper also adds that women carrying mobile phones have been violently attacked by Muslim extremists on Kashmiri streets in recent weeks.
The article in Arabic can be read at:
http://aawsat.com/details.asp?section=4&issue=10045&article=365723.
U.S. POP SHOW VICTOR ATTRACTS MORE VOTES THAN ANY PRESIDENT
As another indication of increasing apathy about politics in the U.S. and elsewhere, Taylor Hicks last week won American Idol, the most popular talent contest in America, if not the world, with a record 63.4 million votes. The host of American Idol, Ryan Seacrest, announced with excitement that the figure was “more than any president in the history of our country has received.”
Hicks is a prematurely gray, chubby-faced 29-year-old singer from Alabama whose husky-voiced soul numbers and quirky dance moves won him an army of fans, according to media reports.
“It is getting to the point where the series has become a conduit for displaced political passion,” wrote Alessandra Stanley in the New York Times. “It is an arena where young people feel that their vote counts.”
-- Tom Gross
IRAN HAS EQUIPPED HIZBULLAH WITH ROCKETS CAPABLE OF HITTING TEL-AVIV
Tel Aviv within range of new Hezbollah rocket
By Zeev Schiff
Ha’aretz
May 29, 2006
www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/720681.html
Iran has equipped the Lebanese-based radical Islamic group Hezbollah with long-range rockets capable of hitting targets up to 200 kilometers away, putting all of Israel’s major urban centers within striking distance.
The solid-fuel rockets lack an independent guidance system and their accuracy is questionable but they can still cause considerable damage.
According to intelligence estimates, the rockets are meant to strike non-specific areas, such as towns and cities, and carry a warhead estimated to weigh 600 kilograms. This latest development doubles the range of weapons previously in Hezbollah’s arsenal.
In this latest transfer of military technology, Iran is seeking to improve its strategic options against Israel rather than better Hezbollah’s capabilities. Equipping a Lebanese group considered by the west to be a terrorist organization with such rockets also poses a danger to Lebanon.
The government of Lebanon has been pressured in the past by Hezbollah to disregard the United Nations Security Council resolution 1559, which demands that all armed militias in the country disarm. Hezbollah maintains that it is not a militia and is therefore not obliged to disarm, but the Security Council has not accepted this argument.
The rockets delivered to the Hezbollah have appeared under different names. One is Zelzal-2, and its earlier model is the Zelzal-1. Another Iranian name for the rocket is Nazeat.
The rocket was first seen in a military parade in Tehran in September 2005, the first such event following the election of Mahmoud Ahmadinejad as president. Six Shehab-3 surface-to-surface ballistic missiles were also on display.
In response to slogans written on the Shehab-3 rockets, calling for “Death to Israel” and “Death to the U.S.,” the military attaches of France, Italy, Greece and Poland, invited to the event, left the VIP platform.
Earlier supplies of rockets to the Hezbollah from Iran via Syria, involved Katyusha rockets with a range of 12-22 kilometers.
These rockets were used on occasion in attacks against Israel.
At later dates the Iranians supplied the Fajr-3 rockets, capable of reaching targets 45 kilometers away. The Hezbollah has never used these weapons.
The Syrians also provided the Hezbollah with rockets of their own make, believed to be of 220mm caliber, whose range is several dozen kilometers.
Iran later provided Hezbollah with Fajr-5 rockets with a range of 75 kilometers; it is capable of striking the Haifa bay and its strategic industrial installations.
The latest Iranian delivery is of rockets whose estimated capability is 200 kilometers (the Zelzal-1 rocket had a range of 150 kilometers). The rocket is 8.3 meters long and is 61mm in diameter. At launch, it weighs about 3.5 tons.
Because the rocket is propelled by solid-fuel, it can be easily moved.
International defense journals have reported that the Iranian rockets have been stored by the Hezbollah in special bunkers in a number of locations in the Bekaa near Lebanon’s border with Syria.
SOLDIERS FOUND A BOMB WEIGHING 15 POUNDS WITH NAILS AND PIECES OF SMALL METAL
Israeli soldiers thwart suicide attack
By Amy Teibel
The Associated Press
May 29, 2006
Israeli soldiers, acting on intelligence reports, prevented two Palestinian militants on Monday from carrying out a suicide bombing inside Israel, the military said. The militants were spotted carrying a suspicious bag near the West Bank city of Nablus and tried to flee, said Lt. Col. Arik Chen, a battalion commander in the Nablus region.
They threw away the bag, then led troops on a three-hour foot chase, until they were cornered and gave themselves up, he said. The men surrendered only after troops fired in the air.
Inside the bag, soldiers found a bomb weighing 15 pounds, packed with nails and pieces of small metal, which heighten the deadly effect, Chen said. Sappers later blew it up.
Security forces had been tipped off late Sunday that militants in the Nablus area were planning an attack inside Israel, and deployed a large number of soldiers around the West Bank town, a militant stronghold, Chen said.
The militants were taken into custody, and in initial questioning, they admitted they planned to blow themselves up in Israel, but did not say where, the army said. They belonged to a cell of activists from the Islamic Jihad, Fatah and Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine militant groups, the military said.
In other news, Israeli soldiers killed an armed Palestinian near the fence separating the Gaza Strip from Israel, the military said.
Soldiers identified three men near the fence, and fired at them, suspecting they intended to carry out an attack, the military said. At least one of the men was hit, and was later evacuated by Palestinian rescue services, it said.
The Popular Resistance Committees, a small Palestinian militant group, identified the man as Abdel Moati Shukri, a group member.
“THE NEW YORK TIMES OWES ITS READERS MORE”
The purpose of checkpoints
By Hillel Halkin
The New York Sun
May 30, 2006
“... The Zaatara checkpoint, where I was waiting, is one of dozens inside the occupied Palestinian territories, restricting the movement of people and goods... I looked at the two young soldiers arrogantly manning the checkpoint, with dozens of people awaiting a sign from them...
“ [A soldier] shouted at a woman holding a crying baby. He ordered her to dump her bag’s contents on the ground... While we waited in a long queue under searing heat, Israeli settlers in air-conditioned vehicles bypassed the checkpoint in their special lane.
“Israel says these measures are vital to stop suicide bombers from flooding into Israeli cities to terrorize the civilian population. But I can’t imagine a suicide bomber standing in a long line deep inside the West Bank, waiting for soldiers to check his ID and car. Determined people can always travel through the hills, avoiding the checkposts.”
– Fareed Tamallah, identified as a Palestinian “peace activist,” writing in a May 25, 2006, New York Times Op-ed.
“This morning, IDF forces arrested a suicide bomber and an aide who were apparently on their way to a terrorist strike within Israel. The two were caught at a surprise checkpoint put up near Nablus...
“Yesterday, as a result of intelligence passed [to the army] by the General Security Service, many checkpoints were put up in the Nablus area. This morning a battalion of the Haruv Brigade spotted the bomber and his aide north of Nablus. The two threw a bag with the bomb in it out the window of their car and tried unsuccessfully to escape. The bag, in which there was a powerful explosive charge, was exploded by sappers of the security forces.”
– MSN Internet news, May 29, 2006
I can assure you that the above news item did not appear in today’s May 30 Times. Why should The Times have published it? It was an incident, after all, in which no one was killed or even wounded. Dozens of Israeli lives may have been saved because of it, but surely one can’t expect The Times to run a story every time a life isn’t lost.
But one can expect even The Times to refrain from publishing blatant anti-Israel idiocy, not only in its own news and feature articles, but in its op-eds that are written by others, too.
Presumably, The Times has one or more op-ed editors. What exactly went through such an editor’s mind when he read Fareed Taamallah’s statement that, “I can’t imagine a suicide bomber standing in a long line deep inside the West Bank, waiting for soldiers to check his ID and car.” Was the editor fast asleep? Why didn’t he or she get on the phone to Mr. Taamallah at once and say:
“Listen, this sentence of yours is absurd. Of course a suicide bomber would be unlikely to stand in a long line deep inside the West Bank waiting to be checked by Israeli soldiers. That’s one reason the checkpoints are there. If they weren’t, what would keep suicide bombers from driving merrily along main highways instead of having to seek out arduous (and, because of Israel’s security fence, increasingly impossible) alternatives? Do me a favor and rewrite those words, please.”
In fact, Mr. Taamallah’s entire op-ed is absurd. Take the poor woman with the baby, the contents of whose bag were dumped on the ground. One sympathizes with her. There should have been a table to dump them on, and one hopes the Israeli army will acquire some for its checkpoints.
But just suppose for a moment that a nice soldier – a most non-arrogant soldier – had felt sorry for the woman and waved her on without emptying her bag. And suppose it soon became known that at Checkpoint X there are nice Israeli soldiers who do such things. How long does Mr. Taamallah – how long does The New York Times – think it would take before a suicide bomber approached such a woman and persuaded her to stick his bomb in her bag? Would our bomber mind “standing in a long line deep inside the West Bank” then?
Indeed, Palestinian women have been caught at checkpoints with bombs in their bags and clothing, just as have Palestinian schoolchildren. The next time Mr. Taamallah sees a schoolchild with tears in its eyes because a checkpoint has made it late for school, he might think of that.
And because the woman with the baby and the child on its way to school are checked thoroughly at checkpoints, and because this takes a long time, and long lines of cars back up on major roads that have good visibility, a suicide bomber who spots such a line ahead of him has plenty of time to turn around and try a back way. And it is precisely when he does that he can be caught at a surprise checkpoint like the one near Nablus yesterday, when coming around a bend in a narrow road he suddenly runs into a barrier that is seen by him when it is already too late.
The checkpoints are a major source of frustration and indignity to the West Bank’s Palestinians and it is understandable that they are resented and hated. It is even understandable that Fareed Taamallah – who, “peace activist” that he may or may not be, clearly doesn’t lose any sleep at night over dead Israelis – should seek to denounce them in a less than honest manner. But The Times owes its readers more. The purpose of the checkpoints is to save Israeli lives, not to embitter Palestinian ones, even if they end up doing both. Surely that’s part of all the news that’s fit to print.
CONTENTS
1. Just how dangerous is Iraq?
2. Da Vinci update: Now Albinos complain
3. Will anyone speak up for the chickens?
4. Targeted assassinations continue
5. Dahlan said to be ultimate Hamas target
6. A humanitarian gesture
7. Guardian anti-Semitism watch
8. BBC as anti-Israel as ever
9. In universities and cafes and on the bus
10. Florida teen’s death called “gift from Allah”
11. Protection racket
12. Israel seizes more explosives at sea
13. Hamas planning 9/11-style attack on Tel Aviv skyscrapers
14. Israeli General skips UK trip over arrest fears
15. Sharon to go to long-term care
This dispatch contains a variety of short items and observations on different matters.
JUST HOW DANGEROUS IS IRAQ?
Congressional Representative Steve King of Iowa this week offered some interesting figures on Iraq. According to Mr. King, the violent death rate in Iraq is 25.71 per 100,000 people per year. That may sound high, but not when you compare it to places like Colombia (61.7), South Africa (49.6), Jamaica (32.4) and Venezuela (31.6).
Challenging King’s figures, opponents of the Iraq war say the death rate in Iraq is in fact 31.03 per 100,000 – a higher rate but still considerably lower than many U.S. cities. New Orleans before Hurricane Katrina was 53.1. FBI statistics for 2004-05 put Washington at 45.9, Baltimore at 37.7 and Atlanta at 34.9.
DA VINCI UPDATE: NOW ALBINOS COMPLAIN
Not only Arab states, some Christians and most film critics are unhappy about the “The Da Vinci Code.”
The Associated Press reports that:
“Albinos are bothered that one of their own has yet again been depicted as a villain…
“Michael McGowan, an albino who heads the National Organization for Albinism and Hypopigmentation, in the U.S., said ‘The Da Vinci Code’ will be the 68th movie since 1960 to feature an evil albino.
“Silas is just the latest in a long string,” McGowan said. “The problem is there has been no balance. There are no realistic, sympathetic or heroic characters with albinism that you can find in movies or popular culture.”
(For more, see: www.msnbc.msn.com/id/12820726/, and “Da Vinci Code” movie banned by Egypt, Lebanon, Syria & Jordan (May 16, 2006).)
WILL ANYONE SPEAK UP FOR THE CHICKENS?
Among the victims of the ongoing (but virtually unreported by most western media) Katyusha rocket attacks fired from the Gaza Strip were 30 chickens that were blown to bits when a chicken coop in the farming community of Nativ Haasara in southern Israel was hit last week.
Fortunately, no human was killed or injured even though the Grad-type Katyusha Rocket carried six kilograms (13 pounds) of explosives.
But also of note is the lack of concern shown about the incident by PETA, a leading animal rights group. PETA infamously complained to Yasser Arafat about his Fatah group using donkeys to carry suicide bombs when one donkey blew up, but when asked by journalists, refused to condemn Arafat for killing Jews with those same bombs.
Please see the dispatch of Feb. 24, 2003, titled Donkeys more important than Israelis, suggests animal rights group.
PETA’s letter to Arafat can be found here: www.peta.org/feat/arafat/
TARGETED ASSASSINATIONS CONTINUE
Senior Hamas and Fatah “military” chiefs continue to be targeted for assassination in Gaza: several have been killed in recent days, along with civilian bystanders, by masked gunmen and roadside bombs. Those carrying out the assassinations are Fatah and Hamas.
When Israel killed some Hamas terrorists, this prompted worldwide outrage. Among those at the forefront of lambasting Israel was UN Secretary General Kofi Annan, the European Union’s “foreign policy chief” Javier Solana, and former British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw. This time, there is virtual silence by the international community.
DAHLAN SAID TO BE ULTIMATE HAMAS TARGET
Fatah chief Mohammed Dahlan is believed to have become the leading target for Hamas in the Gaza Strip. Palestinian security sources said Hamas has been steadily moving toward the elimination of Dahlan in its campaign to control the Gaza Strip. The sources said Hamas has assessed that killing or driving Dahlan into exile would terminate the Fatah threat to them.
“Dahlan, with U.S. money, controls about 3,500 armed, equipped and trained fighters,” a security source said. “He’s the only one Hamas fears.” Hamas’s ally, the Popular Resistance Committees, has threatened Dahlan with assassination. So far, Hamas’s attacks have targeted Dahlan’s allies.
A HUMANITARIAN GESTURE
When the Palestinian Authority Intelligence Chief, Tareq Abu Rajab, an ally of President Mahmoud Abbas, was seriously wounded by a Hamas bomb packed with metal pellets at his headquarters on Saturday, he was transferred to Tel Aviv for medical treatment, where Israeli doctors have saved his life.
Abu Rajab remains at Tel Aviv’s Ichilov Hospital, the same hospital where so many suicide bomb victims, including Danny Wultz, have died. That virtually no media outside Israel have reported on this is surprising.
GUARDIAN ANTI-SEMITISM WATCH
The Guardian’s much-touted blog “Comment Is Free” continues to allow itself to be used as a platform for anti-Semites to air their views.
Last week, for example, the following comment remained on The Guardian website for more than a day after repeated complaints by British Jews:
“There is no ‘global outcry’ because the global media is controlled by International Jewry... Jewish money has seen to it that the Israeli point of view is the dominant one... The Jews by their own grasping, cantankerous, uncompromising, dishonest nature will be the reason for their own destruction in Palestine.”
The Guardian’s reporting is bad enough as it is, with its constant inaccuracies and skewered stories, without now inviting readers of what is supposedly not a racist newspaper, to spread their hate.
British journalist (and subscriber to this email list) Stephen Pollard says some in Britain have dubbed The Guardian’s “Comment Is Free” blog, one of Britain’s most read blogs, “Anti-Semitism is welcome.”
The Guardian’s slanders against Israel, and some would say Jews, is unrelenting. Last week, a writer in The Guardian again compared Rachel Corrie to Anne Frank.
BBC AS ANTI-ISRAEL AS EVER
Following on from the dispatch “The BBC pro-Israeli? Is the Pope Jewish?” (& American teen Danny Wultz dies), May 15, 2006, it looks as if the BBC’s new chief Israel correspondent, Caroline Hawley, may not be that much better than her predecessors, Orla Guerin and Barbara Plett.
In her report on May 23, she questioned why the Israeli army had arrested its most wanted terrorist, Hamas “military” chief in the West Bank Ibrahim Hamad, after years of trying to locate him:
“Hamas has not carried out any suicide attacks for 15 months and Israeli military operations in the past few months have focused instead on the militant Islamic Jihad group, which has been responsible for most of the recent bombs.”
IN UNIVERSITIES AND CAFES AND ON THE BUS
Perhaps for Hawley it’s difficult to understand why Israel would want to arrest a man they have been after for years, who is behind the mass murder of Israeli citizens.
As I pointed out previously, the BBC this month triumphantly reported that its world service radio audience has now risen to 163 million worldwide. Tens of millions of others watch its various TV networks and read its online reporting.
Here, for Hawley’s benefit and for BBC listeners and viewers, are some of the crimes which Hamad, 41, is accused of masterminding (some of which he boasted about organizing):
* The murder of nine people (including five Americans) in a suicide attack in the cafeteria of the Hebrew University of Jerusalem in July 2002
* The March 2002 suicide bombing of the Moment coffee shop in Jerusalem, in which 12 young Israelis including the waitresses were killed
* The attack on the Sheffield pool hall in Rishon Lezion in May 2002, which killed 16 people
* The double suicide bombing and simultaneous car bombing in central Jerusalem in 2001, in which 11 people were killed and dozens injured
* The double suicide bombing in September 2003, which killed a total of 17 people at the Hillel Cafe in Jerusalem’s German Colony, and at the Tsrifin junction
Hamad has boasted of his part in organizing the murder of dozens of civilians. That is why he has been arrested. Hawley might also have told her audience that the Israelis managed to locate Hamad in a building just yards from Mahmoud Abbas’s Ramallah HQ. Could it be that now that Hamas has turned its guns on Fatah, Abbas gave him up?
For more on Hawley, who says her “romantic memories of camels in deserts and starry nights” when she grew up in Oman, inspired her to study Arabic and Islamic studies at Oxford University, see the dispatch “Possibly the most maligned country on the planet is in the news again” (March 16, 2006).
FLORIDA TEEN’S DEATH CALLED “GIFT FROM ALLAH”
The death of Daniel Wultz, the Florida teenager critically injured in the Tel Aviv suicide bomb last month, who died last week, has been welcomed as a “gift from Allah” by Abu Nasser, a leader of the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades. He said he was especially happy when American Jews died.
The Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades was set up by Yasser Arafat after he launched his Intifada. Much of its weaponry was bought with European Union aid money.
PROTECTION RACKET
Last week, in a leaflet issued in the Gaza Strip, the Al Aqsa Martyrs Brigades threatened to strike at European interests if the European Union didn’t give their parent party, Fatah, more money – a day later several European diplomats indeed called on the EU to rush another bundle of European taxpayers’ money to Fatah-related “non-government” organizations.
Only last week, yet another senior Palestinian official – Fuad Hejazi Muhammad Shubaki, from Gaza, admitted that international funds transferred to the PA were used to finance arms purchases. Shubaki, who was in charge of finances for the PA General Security service, said that from 2000 onwards, Arafat personally ordered him to use international aid money to purchase large quantities of weapons for the Al-Aqsa Martyrs Brigades.
Instead of just continuing to give Palestinian gunmen money, could not the EU condition offer of future aid upon guns and rockets being handed in by Palestinians, in return?
Yesterday, Fatah and Hamas gunmen were engaged in a shootout at Gaza’s Shifa hospital. But most western media failed to report this and instead showed patients in Palestinian hospitals in an effort to try convince viewers that there are somehow more sick people in Gaza hospitals than hospitals elsewhere in the world.
ISRAEL SEIZES MORE EXPLOSIVES AT SEA
While the Palestinian Authority continues to tell gullible CNN journalists that they have no money, Israel continues to try and intercept the large quantities of weapons being smuggled into Gaza.
Last Sunday, for the second time in a week, the Israeli navy intercepted a shipment of explosives heading to Gaza. Again, the incident began when Israeli seamen spotted a Palestinian vessel crossing the Israeli-declared “no-sail zone” off the southern Gaza coast and into Egyptian waters. When the same vessel returned to the zone sailing in the direction of the Gaza coast, it was ordered by the Israeli navy to stop. Following the firing of warning shots and a sea-chase during which bags were thrown overboard, the boat was seized and searched. Several hundred pounds of high-grade explosives and parts of mines were discovered.
HAMAS PLANNING 9/11-STYLE ATTACK ON TEL AVIV SKYSCRAPERS
Abu Abdullah, a leader of Hamas’ military wing, has threatened to attack Israel using small airplanes containing explosives to be flown into important targets in Israel. Palestinian security officials believe Hamas recently smuggled three small airplanes into the Gaza Strip.
Abdullah said: “The goal is to have these planes carry maximum quantities of explosives and that they will be able to hit the targets that are fixed for its operation at a high level of accuracy… We will choose precious targets and I do not want to speak about strategic or any other targets... We know that the enemy is building new and high buildings in Tel Aviv.”
ISRAELI GENERAL SKIPS UK TRIP OVER ARREST FEARS
Agence France Presse reports that the Israeli Army has scrapped plans to send one of its generals on a course at a British military academy over fears he could be arrested on war-crime allegations. General Aviv Kohavi, commander of the division which protects southern Israel from ongoing Palestinian rocket fire, had been due to attend the prestigious Sandhurst Royal Academy.
Last September, a retired Israeli soldier, Doron Almog, refused to leave a plane at London’s Heathrow airport after learning a warrant had been issued for his arrest over his time commanding troops in Gaza.
Almog was due to give a talk in Britain about a charitable project he is involved with in the Negev that helps Israeli Jews and Arabs with severe mental and physical disabilities. (Almog’s own child is severely disabled.) For more, see Islamic militant Hizb ut-Tahrir infiltrates Reuters (& Prince Harry apologizes) (Sept. 15, 2005).
INCREDIBLE DOUBLE STANDARDS
In March of this year, Major-General Salah Abdullah Gosh, the man accused of being one of the main instigators of the ongoing genocide in Darfur, visited Britain. The British Foreign Office, then headed by Jack Straw, granted him a visa despite UN sanctions against Sudan. During his stay Gosh received “medical treatment,” and also met with unnamed British government officials.
During the last week, over 300 people, almost all Afghans, have been killed in heavy fighting in Afghanistan. British troops were involved in the assault, which included British apache attack gunships. Is Britain also going to arrest its own military commanders for “war crimes”?
SHARON TO GO TO LONG-TERM CARE
Ariel Sharon is to be moved to a long-term care facility next week. The Israeli newspaper Ma’ariv reports that doctors believe there is no chance that the former Israeli prime minister, who was felled by a stroke in January, will regain consciousness.
Sharon is expected to be moved from the intensive care unit at Jerusalem’s Hadassah Hospital in Ein Kerem to a coma ward at Shiba Hospital in Tel Hashomer. The Knesset Finance Committee last week approved state funding for the next five years of Sharon’s hospital treatment.
-- Tom Gross
* “Holocost” rap duo conquers Paris
* Suffering of Jewish scientists deported by Britain to Australia in appalling conditions n 1940 revealed by new film, news reports, despite still being under embargo by Britain’s Official Secrets Act until 2040
* German Pope to visit Auschwitz on Sunday
CONTENTS
1. A German Pope goes to Auschwitz
2. “They think I’ve got a screw loose”
3. The darker side of Britain’s fight against Nazi Germany
4. In Italy, separation fence compared to Auschwitz
5. “Ala. Democrats scramble to bounce Shoah denier from primary ballot” (Forward, May 19, 2006)
6. “Film shows suffering of Jews Britain sent to Outback exile” (Daily Telegraph, May 17, 2006)
7. “Matthias Goering goes kosher” (Der Spiegel, May 10, 2006)
8. “Yad Vashem for renaming Auschwitz” (Associated Press, May 11, 2006)
9. “A German pope’s duty at Auschwitz” (International Herald Tribune, May 12, 2006)
10. “Italy: Holocaust cartoon stirs row” (Yediot Ahronot, May 14, 2006)
11. “Nazis ‘shipped arms to Palestinians’” (Yediot Ahronot, May 7, 2006)
12 “BBC to make Nazi trial epic” (The Guardian, May 8, 2006)
13. “‘Holocost’ rap duo conquers Paris” (Yediot Ahronot, May 15, 2006)
14. “‘More than 3000 Mountain Jews were killed by Armenians during 1918-1919’” (Today. AZ, April 21, 2006)
15. “Armenians believe that Jews made Turks and Armenians hostile” (Journal of Turkish Weekly, May 17, 2006)
A GERMAN POPE GOES TO AUSCHWITZ
Tomorrow Pope Benedict XVI begins a four-day tour of Poland, his first since the German cardinal, a former Hitler Youth, acceded to the papacy. On Sunday he will visit Auschwitz after paying homage to the nearby birthplace of John Paul II, who died in April of last year. John Paul II visited the former death camp on his first visit to Poland as pope in 1979. Writing in the International Herald Tribune (article below) Timothy W. Ryback says: “If he was able to speak as a German to the dead Waffen SS soldiers in La Cambe two years ago, let’s hope Benedict XVI can do the same for Germany’s victims at Auschwitz.”
A church official said yesterday that Benedict will now walk into the Auschwitz death camp, dropping plans to enter by car, in order to honor the camp’s inmates, who also had to enter on foot. The pope had planned to drive under the infamous words “Arbeit macht Frei” – Work Sets You Free – in his popemobile, before the Polish organizers pointed out to him that Nazi commanders and troops drove through the gate in cars, while the inmates were forced to walk.
“THEY THINK I’VE GOT A SCREW LOOSE”
Partly to mark this occasion, I attach a series of articles relating to the Holocaust. Of particular interest may be the interview with Matthias Goering, a descendant of Hermann Goering, Adolf Hitler’s right-hand man. After 44 years of “despising Jews” Matthias Goering, a 49-year-old physiotherapist, has become “a full-on Israel lover.” He wears a skullcap, keeps kosher, celebrates the Jewish Sabbath, is learning Hebrew and is even considering converting to Judaism.
Goering, who now volunteers to work with the Israeli victims of suicide bombings, admits his family thinks he has “got a screw loose.”
Goering is not the only Nazi descendent to feel drawn to Israel. Katrin Himmler, the great-niece of SS commander Heinrich Himmler, is married to an Israeli. Last year she published a book denouncing her uncle’s war crimes.
THE DARKER SIDE OF BRITAIN’S FIGHT AGAINST NAZI GERMANY
The second article below concerns the horror experienced by Jewish and anti-Nazi outcasts shipped to the Australian Outback by the British Government during the war. It has been documented in a new Australian film that highlights the darker side of Britain’s fight against Nazi Germany. The filmmakers say the episode is well known in Australia, but in the UK it is still under embargo by Britain’s Official Secrets Act until 2040.
The 2,500 internees, including many scientists, academics and artists who had fled to Britain from Nazi Austria and Germany, were dispatched by ship from Liverpool in July 1940 on the orders of Winston Churchill.
They endured appalling conditions. According to the (London) Daily Telegraph, “They were stripped of their personal possessions, including documents and false teeth, many of which were thrown away [by the British troops guarding them]. They were beaten and insulted as ‘Jewish swine’ and forced to sleep on floors awash with human waste.”
“Their arrival in Australia was seen as the greatest injection of talent to enter Australia on a single vessel,” according to the Daily Telegraph. After the war most stayed in Australia, only a handful returned to Britain.
IN ITALY, SEPARATION FENCE COMPARED TO AUSCHWITZ
Other articles in this dispatch report on how the Italian Communist Party is refusing to apologize for an anti-Semitic caricature that shows Israel’s separation fence with a welcome sign paraphrasing Auschwitz’s “Work Liberates,” how French rappers are misusing the Holocaust, and new records that reveal greater collaboration than previously thought between Palestinian Arab nationalists and the Nazis.
ON TURKS, ARMENIANS AND BLAMING THE JEWS
On a separate note, I also attach a report: “More than 3000 Mountain Jews were killed by Armenians during 1918-1919,” and an anti-Semitic text in this week’s Turkish Weekly, falsely charging “that the Jews encouraged the Ottoman Turks to commit genocide against Armenians.”
There are summaries first for those who don’t have time to read the articles in full.
-- Tom Gross
SUMMARIES
DEMOCRATIC CANDIDATE FOR ALABAMA ATTORNEY GENERAL EXPOSED AS A HOLOCAUST DENIER
“Ala. Democrats scramble to bounce Shoah denier from primary ballot” (By Jennifer Siegel, Forward, May 19, 2006, www.forward.com/articles/7814; Summary only)
A Democratic Party candidate for Alabama’s attorney general’s office has been exposed as a Holocaust denier less than a month before the state’s June 6 primaries. Larry Darby believes that there were no more than 140,000 Jewish deaths during World War II – most of them having been brought on by typhus – and that the historically accepted figure of 6 million killed is a lie promoted by the “Holocaust industry,” The Associated Press reported last week.
The revelation about Darby has sent the state’s Democratic Party scrambling to keep him out of the two-way primary, which also includes Mobile County’s district attorney, John Tyson Jr… Darby, a self-described Dixiecrat, reportedly favors the imposition of martial law to stop illegal emigration from Mexico. “Someone needs to speak up for the white man,” he told the Decatur Daily News. “It’s been a long time since someone took up that bat and took a swing for the white man.”
He also said that Alabama should recall its National Guard troops from Iraq because “they are fighting for Israeli interests and not for Alabama or United States interests.”
Although Darby’s antisemitism did not draw widespread attention until last week, the candidate was previously involved with prominent Holocaust deniers. One of them is David Irving, to whom he played host at a meeting last July…
Last weekend, Darby traveled to Elmwood Park, N.J., to attend a meeting of the New Jersey unit of the National Vanguard, including David Duke…
“THE GREATEST INJECTION OF TALENT TO ENTER AUSTRALIA ON A SINGLE VESSEL”
“Film shows suffering of Jews Britain sent to Outback exile” (By Kate Connolly, The Daily Telegraph, U.K., May 17, 2006)
The horror experienced by Jewish and anti-Nazi outcasts shipped to the Australian Outback by the British Government during the war has been documented in a new film that highlights the darker side of Britain’s fight against Nazi Germany.
The men, mainly scientists, academics and artists who had fled to Britain from Nazi Austria and Germany at the outbreak of the war, were considered a security threat after the fall of France. On the orders of Winston Churchill, they were dispatched from Liverpool on the Hired Military Transport ship Dunera in July 1940.
Their arrival in Australia – after a 57-day journey in appalling conditions – was seen as the greatest injection of talent to enter Australia on a single vessel.
They were taken to a detention camp in the Outback, where they set up an impromptu university to pass the time… Among the passengers were Franz Stampfl, the athletics coach to the four-minute-mile runner Roger Bannister, Wolf Klaphake, the inventor of synthetic camphor, and the photographer Henry Talbot.
… Watched over by 309 poorly trained British soldiers, the men endured horrendous conditions. They were stripped of their personal possessions, including documents and false teeth, many of which were thrown overboard. They were beaten and insulted as “Jewish swine” and forced to sleep below deck on floors awash with human waste. The hatches and portholes were battened shut…
Klaus Wilcynski, 86, author of The Prison Ship, recalled being told to walk on the deck in bare feet. “Soldiers had smashed beer bottles so people cut their feet.”…
MATTHIAS GOERING GOES KOSHER
“Matthias Goering goes kosher” (By Ruth Elkins, Der Spiegel, May 10, 2006)
Growing up with the name Goering wasn’t easy for the descendents of Hitler’s right-hand man Hermann Goering. One of them has now discovered a love for Israeli wine – and is considering converting to Judaism…
… Even so, it is very odd to be having lunch in a Jewish restaurant with a direct descendent of Adolf Hitler’s right-hand man. Matthias Goering, though, couldn’t be happier here. After 44 years of “despising Jews” and suffering the curse of his family name, the 49-year-old physiotherapist has become a full-on Israel lover. He wears a kippa, keeps kosher, celebrates Shabbat, is learning Hebrew and is even considering converting. His family thinks he has gone mad.
“They think I’ve got a screw loose,” grins the man who now works with the victims of suicide bombings. “But I know what has happened to me is completely and utterly real.”
Despite only having a distant tie to the Nazi Luftwaffe Chief – Matthias’s great grandfather’s brother was Hermann Goering’s grandfather’s brother...
Matthias Goering, with his bright blue eyes and Star of David necklace, is not the only Nazi descendent to feel drawn to Israel. Katrin Himmler, the great-niece of Heinrich Himmler, published a book last year exploring the SS commander’s war crimes and asking the question: What does it mean to be a Himmler? She married an Israeli, saying “it was as if we were predestined to meet.” Her book, “The Brothers Himmler”, is the latest in a flourishing genre in Germany of Nazi descendents trying to come to terms with the curse of their family histories…
Beate Niemann, daughter of feared SS Major Bruno Sattler, made a prize-winning film, “The Good Father” which documented her hopeless search for a man she could be proud of. Instead, she found herself seeking apologies from Jewish camp survivors in Eastern Europe after discovering her father was a mass murderer who ordered the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Jews. Monika Goeth, daughter of Amon Goeth – the Plaszow Concentration camp commandant who would randomly shoot Jewish laborers from his villa balcony – has also spent years seeking rapprochement with those who survived her father’s crimes. “I am completely drawn to Judaism,” she said last year on the 60th anniversary of the Liberation of Auschwitz. “Jews were the real heroes and I feel nothing but contempt for those who still idolize the Nazis.”
… “My parents seemed to have to lose any religious belief they had after the war,” says Goering. “When the other school children had religious instruction, my siblings and I were forced to sit alone out in the corridor.” Money was tight. “Our parents would always say to us: ‘you can’t have that, because all our money’s gone to the Jews,’” he says. “They became a symbol of everything we couldn’t have.”…
Goering now wants to write a book on his experiences. “The Israelis are so friendly to me,” he says. Even when they find out your name? “Yes, they say they’re so thankful I’ve made contact,” says Goering. “I used to feel cursed by having the name Goering,” he smiles. “Now I feel blessed.”
YAD VASHEM SUPPORTS POLAND’S BID TO RENAME AUSCHWITZ
“Yad Vashem for renaming Auschwitz” (The Associated Press, May 11, 2006; summary only, for space reasons)
Yad Vashem supports Poland in its attempt to officially rename Auschwitz to emphasize that German Nazis ran the death camp, but has asked for an additional change, the director of the Israeli Holocaust memorial said. Poland’s government requested in March that UNESCO change the official name of Auschwitz on its world heritage registry from “Auschwitz Concentration Camp” to “Former Nazi German Concentration Camp Auschwitz-Birkenau.”
Foreign media sometime refer to Auschwitz – a death camp located in occupied Poland where Nazi Germany killed more than 1 million people – as a “Polish concentration camp.” Such phrasing deeply wounds sensitivities in Poland, which was subjected to a brutal occupation by Adolf Hitler’s forces.
Avner Shalev, Yad Vashem’s director general, said his group supports Poland’s wish to see Nazi German guilt emphasized in the name, but also wants the word “extermination” added to underline that Adolf Hitler’s regime sought to wipe out European Jewry.
“You can’t skip the word ‘extermination,’” Shalev told The Associated Press during a visit to Warsaw. “This is important from the point of view of historical objectivity. Birkenau was the largest death camp that served as a major tool of the Final Solution. It was an industry and its purpose was the murder of the Jews in Europe until the very last person.”
… The matter would be decided at an annual gathering of member states this July in Vilnius, Lithuania.
A GERMAN POPE’S DUTY AT AUSCHWITZ
“A German pope’s duty at Auschwitz” (By Timothy W. Ryback, The International Herald Tribune, May 12, 2006)
Pope Benedict XVI will visit Auschwitz on his scheduled trip to Poland later this month. This will be his second Auschwitz visit. In 1979, when Joseph Ratzinger was archbishop of Munich, he accompanied Pope John Paul II to the former Nazi death camp, where they celebrated Holy Communion.
“It was a moving idea and a moving moment to look across these horrific fields of death in which four million human beings lost their lives, and to experience the resurrection as the only true and only adequate response,” he told a group of German priests afterward. There was no talk of personal remorse, no mention of German guilt. It was a singularly Catholic experience…
When Benedict XVI returns to Auschwitz [next week], a quarter century after his last visit, he will arrive not only as the leader of the world’s one billion Roman Catholics, but also as the most prominent moral spokesman for 80 million Germans. It will be an opportunity rich in symbolic and moral potential: a former Hitler Youth passing through the gates of a former Nazi death camp as one of the world’s leading spiritual authorities…
Let’s hope Benedict XVI brings his full moral authority, his eloquence and his insight, to help us better understand the historical and moral responsibilities of the German people 60 years after the Holocaust. If he was able to speak as a German to the dead Waffen SS soldiers in La Cambe two years ago, let’s hope he can do the same for Germany’s victims at Auschwitz this spring.
ANTI-SEMITIC CARICATURE PUBLISHED BY ITALIAN COMMUNIST PARTY
“Italy: Holocaust cartoon stirs row” (By Yossi Bar, Yediot Ahronot, May 14, 2006)
An anti-Semitic cartoon which appeared Friday in Liberzione, the journal of the Italian Communist Party, stirred a row among Italian Jews, the Israeli Embassy and parliament members.
The journal of the Rifondazione Communista party, set to be part of the coalition that will form the Italian government, published an anti-Semitic caricature showing the separation fence with a gate bearing the sign “Hunger Liberates,” similar to the welcome sign at the entrance to the Auschwitz extermination camp, which read “Work Liberates.”…
… However, Italian Lower Chamber Speaker Fausto Bertinotti, leader of the Communist party, as well as other party members, did not apologize and failed to even respond to the cartoon publication.
“ARABS ADMIRE OUR FUHRER”
“Nazis ‘shipped arms to Palestinians’” (By Yaakov Lappin, Yediot Ahronot, May 7, 2006)
Historical documents in Britain’s National Archives in London show that Nazi Germany attempted to ship arms to Palestinian forces in the 1930s.
A British Foreign Office report from 1939 reports of “news of a consignment of arms from Germany, sent via Turkey and addressed to Ibn Saud (king of Saudi Arabia), but really intended for the Palestine insurgents.” Britain’s chief military officer in Mandatory Palestine also noted reports “regarding import of German arms at intervals for some years now.”…
One Nazi agent, Adam Vollhardt, arrived in Palestine in July 1938, and was reported to have gained strong influence with Arab leaders, meeting with Palestinian leaders throughout 1938. Vollhardt held several meetings with leading Arab politicians and told them “that the Palestine question would be settled to the satisfaction of the Arabs within a few weeks,” adding that “it would be fatal to their (Palestinians’) cause if at this juncture they showed any signs of weakness or exhaustion.”…
German documents photographed and sent to Whitehall by an American spy revealed that in 1937, German officials had calculated that “Palestine under Arab rule would… become one of the few countries where we could count on a strong sympathy for the new Germany.”
“The Palestinian Arabs show on all levels a great sympathy for the new Germany and its Fuhrer, a sympathy whose value is particularly high as it is based on a purely ideological foundation,” a Nazi official in Palestine wrote in a letter to Berlin in 1937.
… The records also show that the news of increased Nazi-Arab cooperation panicked the British government, and caused it to cancel a plan in 1938 to bring to Palestine 20,000 German Jewish refugees, half of them children, facing danger from the Nazis…
BBC TO SCREEN “EPIC” DOCUDRAMA OF NUREMBERG TRIALS
“BBC to make Nazi trial epic” (By Leigh Holmwood, The Guardian, May 8, 2006)
The BBC is to mark the 60th anniversary of the trial of Nazi leaders at Nuremberg by screening an “epic” docudrama series telling the behind-the-scenes story. The Nuremberg Trial – Inside the Nazi Mind, which will be made in partnership with Discovery, will be based on trial transcripts and new sources unearthed by the production team.
… The docudrama will be the BBC’s major historical series this year and follows previous landmark programmes such as last year’s six-part history of the Auschwitz concentration camp and Nazis – a Warning from History.
“HOLOCOST” RAP DUO CONQUERS PARIS
“‘Holocost’ rap duo conquers Paris” (By Sefi Hendler, Yediot Ahronot, May 15, 2006)
A French rap duo calling themselves “Holocost” caused a stir in Paris recently after they pasted promotional posters up around the city announcing the release of their new album. The black posters with the word “Holocost” printed in yellow and an image of an automatic weapon were seen throughout the French city and its suburbs.
… The lyrics of Holocost’s songs express severe social criticism directed chiefly towards French society. In one of their songs they sings, “When the police come to my ghetto, it’s an Intifada, Palestine.” The album, which was released in mid-April, was well received in the rap community according to reviews in online rap websites and blogs.
… Saban noted that the suburban rap scene has also seen anti-Semitic songs in the past. “There was a rap song called ‘Screw the Jews’ a year or two ago. There was an investigation launched, but the clip was anonymous and no band took responsibility for it,” Saban said. Prominent figures in the Jewish community in Paris said that they have no intention of protesting the musical group. “Why should we give them free publicity?” they explained.
“MORE THAN 3000 MOUNTAIN JEWS WERE KILLED BY ARMENIANS DURING 1918-1919”
“‘More than 3000 Mountain Jews were killed by Armenians during 1918-1919’” (By Rovshan Mustafayev, Today.AZ, April 21, 2006)
… Semen Ikhiilov, Head of Mountain Jews’ community, writes to the Human Rights Institute of the National Academy of Science: “In 1980s I discovered unknown facts regarding to mass killings of Jews during the period of Azerbaijanis’ genocide in 1918-1919. According to the witnesses and some documents, together with Azerbaijanis more than 3000 Jews were killed. For the moment we identified 87 names. Each year on March 31st, on the day of Azerbaijanis’ genocide of 1918-1919, special requiem prayers for 87 killed Jewish children, women and men are being read in the synagogues. We continue the researches of other places of mass burial in the regions of our Motherland, Azerbaijan. This letter is accompanied with the list of victims, who were killed by monsters on 19th Iyar, 5679, in Guba city,” the letter says…
After we received the message from Jewish community the experts group was created for working with archives. We discovered this mass killings were committed by group headed by Amazasp under Stepan Shaumian’s command…
There will be a statue erected by Mountain Jews in memory of the victims and the names will be written there. That’s why the complete identification is needed…
“JEWS ENCOURAGED THE OTTOMAN TURKS TO COMMIT GENOCIDE AGAINST ARMENIANS”
“Armenians believe that Jews made Turks and Armenians hostile” (The Journal of Turkish Weekly, May 17, 2006, www.turkishweekly.net/news.php?id=31932
Summary Only.)
… Turkish journalist Mrs. Ece Temelkuran’s interviews from Armenia continue in Turkish daily Milliyet newspaper. In today’s part (17 May 2006) Turkish journalist Ece Temelkuran met with Arsak Sarkisyan:
Sarkisyan argues that the Jews encouraged the Ottoman Turks to commit genocide against Armenians. Sarkisyan continues: “Talat Pasha was a Jewish. They made Turks and Armenians hostile. Turks would not have committed genocide. But all of the Jon Turks (Young Turks) were Jewish”.
FILM SHOWS SUFFERING OF JEWS BRITAIN SENT TO OUTBACK EXILE
Film shows suffering of Jews Britain sent to Outback exile
By Kate Connolly
Daily Telegraph, U.K.
May 17, 2006
The horror experienced by Jewish and anti-Nazi outcasts shipped to the Australian Outback by the British Government during the war has been documented in a new film that highlights the darker side of Britain’s fight against Nazi Germany.
The men, mainly scientists, academics and artists who had fled to Britain from Nazi Austria and Germany at the outbreak of the war, were considered a security threat after the fall of France.
On the orders of Winston Churchill, they were dispatched from Liverpool on the Hired Military Transport (HMT) ship Dunera in July 1940.
Their arrival in Australia – after a 57-day journey in appalling conditions – was seen as the greatest injection of talent to enter Australia on a single vessel.
They were taken to a detention camp in the Outback, where they set up an impromptu university to pass the time.
Among the passengers were Franz Stampfl, the athletics coach to the four-minute-mile runner Roger Bannister, Wolf Klaphake, the inventor of synthetic camphor, and the photographer Henry Talbot.
John Burgan, 44, the director of Friendly Enemy Alien, which premiered in Berlin this week, said he made the film to illustrate that, while refugees are often seen as a burden, they contribute a lot to the countries in which they settle.
“Refugees are invariably unwanted and unloved when they arrive, but being at the bottom of the heap they knuckle down and make the best of the chance they’ve been given, to become an asset to their adopted country,” said Mr Burgan.
“Nowhere is that better illustrated than with the story of the Dunera boys, many of whom had lost everything in the Holocaust. They made the best of what they had.”
When the overcrowded Dunera set sail from Liverpool, its 2,500 internees were told they were bound for Canada.
Watched over by 309 poorly trained British soldiers, the men endured horrendous conditions. They were stripped of their personal possessions, including documents and false teeth, many of which were thrown overboard. They were beaten and insulted as “Jewish swine” and forced to sleep below deck on floors awash with human waste. The hatches and portholes were battened shut.
“There was so little air that to get the job of peeling potatoes on deck was seen as a life-saver,” said Walter Kaufmann, 82, a Jewish refugee now living in Berlin whose book Touching Time details the Dunera experience.
Klaus Wilcynski, 86, author of The Prison Ship, recalled being told to walk on the deck in bare feet. “Soldiers had smashed beer bottles so people cut their feet.”
Mr Burgan said the story was well-known in Australia. But it is still under embargo by Britain’s Official Secrets Act until 2040.
The medical army officer Alan Frost, who was the first Australian to go on board when the Dunera docked at Sydney’s Darling Harbour, was appalled by the conditions.
His report led to the court martial of the officer-in-charge, Lt Colonel William Scott.
When the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbour, the men were reclassified as “friendly aliens”, and hundreds were recruited into the Australian army. After the war most stayed in Australia. Only a handful returned to Britain and several to East Germany.
“I HAD TO GO TO ISRAEL”
Matthias Goering goes kosher
By Ruth Elkins
Der Spiegel
May 10, 2006
service.spiegel.de/cache/international/0,1518,415430,00.html
Growing up with the name Goering wasn’t easy for the descendents of Hitler’s right-hand man Hermann Goering. One of them has now discovered a love for Israeli wine – and is considering converting to Judaism.
Mr. Goering is determined to discover the origin of the wine we’re drinking. The waiter, an old man with snow white hair and a dark blue kippa, toddles over and says: “It’s from a small vineyard near Haifa, Sir.” Goering leans back in his chair, satisfied. “Ah, Israeli wine,” he sighs, “Perfect.”
That’s Matthias Goering, not Hermann. Even so, it is very odd to be having lunch in a Jewish restaurant with a direct descendent of Adolf Hitler’s right-hand man. Matthias Goering, though, couldn’t be happier here. After 44 years of “despising Jews” and suffering the curse of his family name, the 49-year-old physiotherapist has become a full-on Israel lover. He wears a kippa, keeps kosher, celebrates Shabbat, is learning Hebrew and is even considering converting. His family thinks he has gone mad.
“They think I’ve got a screw loose,” grins the man who now works with the victims of suicide bombings. “But I know what has happened to me is completely and utterly real.”
Despite only having a distant tie to the Nazi Luftwaffe Chief – Matthias’s great grandfather’s brother was Hermann Goering’s grandfather’s brother – his own branch of the Goerings suffered after the fall of the Third Reich. “It wasn’t the happiest of childhoods,” he says. “The Goering name meant my siblings and I were bullied mercilessly.”
“I had to go to Israel”
After leaving home at 18 to join the circus, Goering eventually carved out a normal life. He became a physiotherapist, married and had a son. Life was good. But it didn’t last.
By 2000, Goering’s Swiss physiotherapy practice had gone bankrupt and his wife had left him, taking their son with her. Broke and lonely, Goering was close to suicide. For the first time in his life he prayed. “I told God, ‘if you really exist, I need your help. Not in two weeks, right now. If you help me I’ll do whatever you want.’” A few minutes later, Goering’s phone rang. It was physiotherapy practice near Zurich offering him job. “I couldn’t believe it,” says Goering. “I spent the next couple of years popping into every church I saw to say thank you”.
Two years later came a second sign. “I awoke at dawn and God told me: ‘I want you to guard the gates of Jerusalem,’” says Goering. “I said, ‘hang on, you know my name, I think you’ve got the wrong man’. But he said, ‘no, you.’ I knew then,” he says, “I had to go to Israel.”
Matthias Goering, with his bright blue eyes and Star of David necklace, is not the only Nazi descendent to feel drawn to Israel.
Katrin Himmler, the great-niece of Heinrich Himmler, published a book last year exploring the SS commander’s war crimes and asking the question: What does it mean to be a Himmler? She married an Israeli, saying “it was as if we were predestined to meet.” Her book, “The Brothers Himmler”, is the latest in a flourishing genre in Germany of Nazi descendents trying to come to terms with the curse of their family histories.
Propelled by guilt
Beate Niemann, daughter of feared SS Major Bruno Sattler, made a prize-winning film, “The Good Father” which documented her hopeless search for a man she could be proud of. Instead, she found herself seeking apologies from Jewish camp survivors in Eastern Europe after discovering her father was a mass murderer who ordered the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Jews. Monika Goeth, daughter of Amon Goeth – the Plaszow Concentration camp commandant who would randomly shoot Jewish laborers from his villa balcony – has also spent years seeking rapprochement with those who survived her father’s crimes. “I am completely drawn to Judaism,” she said last year on the 60th anniversary of the Liberation of Auschwitz. “Jews were the real heroes and I feel nothing but contempt for those who still idolize the Nazis.”
Such personal expeditions into the soul of a nation attempting to deal with war guilt appear a natural reflex; a simple exercise in quashing guilt feelings by embracing the culture of the Nazi’s victims. But Matthias Goering believes his religious conversion is more than that.
“I don’t feel any guilt, myself,” he says. “There is a spiritual guilt in our family, guilt in the German nation and it is our responsibility to declare it openly. I think God is taking this opportunity to use my name to change something in the hearts of others.”
But as Matthias tucks into his Kosher Schwarma and shows off his orange anti-disengagement bracelet protesting Israeli withdrawal from the occupied territories (the Hebrew inscription reads: “Jews don’t evict Jews”), one can’t help but wonder whether part of his enthusiasm for Jewish life is connected with a deep yearning for a place in a community, away from Germany and his family’s Nazi past, to call home.
Before the war, the Goerings were an affluent, tight-knit family. Hermann Goering’s extravagant lifestyle was legendary. His luxury villas, hand-made uniforms and looted art gave him the most raffish image of the Nazi elite. But after the Third Reich’s collapse, the money and security vanished. The Goering name was in tatters. “The family lost touch with each other. It was every man for himself,” says Goering.
Feeling blessed to be a Goering
Matthias’s father, Ernst Wilhelm Goering, a military doctor, was a prisoner of war in the Soviet Union after the war. When he returned to Germany he set up a surgery near Heidelberg. “Then a 14-year-old boy my father was treating for bulimia died,” sighs Goering. The town started a witch hunt. “They said: you’ve killed him, just like your family killed the Jews.” Ernst Wilhelm was sent back to jail.
“My parents seemed to have to lose any religious belief they had after the war,” says Goering. “When the other school children had religious instruction, my siblings and I were forced to sit alone out in the corridor.” Money was tight. “Our parents would always say to us: ‘you can’t have that, because all our money’s gone to the Jews,’” he says. “They became a symbol of everything we couldn’t have.”
“Certainly guilt is a big motivating factor,” says Dr. Sara Savage, social psychologist at Cambridge University who has researched extensively into the psychology of religious conversion. “But there is also a recognized psychological phenomenon whereby ‘outsiders’ yearn to be associated with a ‘winning group’ in society.”
Back in Basel’s Topas Jewish restaurant Matthias Goering is telling me about the beauty of the Golan Heights. “The warmth of the sun is heavenly,” he sighs, “you can pick fresh mangoes and dates off the trees. It’s wonderful”. Would he ever move to Israel? “I would go tomorrow if I could,” he says. “It feels like home.”
Goering now wants to write a book on his experiences. “The Israelis are so friendly to me.” he says. Even when they find out your name? “Yes, they say they’re so thankful I’ve made contact,” says Goering. “I used to feel cursed by having the name Goering,” he smiles. “Now I feel blessed.”
A GERMAN POPE’S DUTY AT AUSCHWITZ
A German pope’s duty at Auschwitz
By Timothy W. Ryback
The International Herald Tribune
May 12, 2006
www.iht.com/articles/2006/05/12/opinion/edryback.php
The Vatican recently announced that Pope Benedict XVI will visit Auschwitz on his scheduled trip to Poland later this month. This will be his second Auschwitz visit. In 1979, when Joseph Ratzinger was archbishop of Munich, he accompanied Pope John Paul II to the former Nazi death camp, where they celebrated Holy Communion.
“It was a moving idea and a moving moment to look across these horrific fields of death in which four million human beings lost their lives, and to experience the resurrection as the only true and only adequate response,” he told a group of German priests afterward. There was no talk of personal remorse, no mention of German guilt. It was a singularly Catholic experience.
When Benedict attended the 60th anniversary commemoration two years ago of the D-Day landings in Normandy, he cast aside his Vatican identity to bare his German soul. The day before he appeared with Queen Elizabeth II, Jacques Chirac, Gerhard Schroder and George W. Bush for the official events on the beach at Arromanches, he visited a German military cemetery at La Cambe, where 21,000 German soldiers are buried, among them several hundred former members of the notorious Waffen SS, some of whom participated in the massacre of hundreds of men, women and children in the French village of Oradour-sur-Glane.
“As Germans we cannot help but be moved to realize that their idealism and their duty to the state was misused by an unjust government,” Benedict said of the war dead at La Cambe. He expressed regret that the Germanic virtue of obedience – Pflicht – had been exploited and misused by the Nazis, and said that this did nothing to diminish their honor or service to the Fatherland.
As with Auschwitz, there was no talk of personal culpability, not a word about German guilt. “They simply tried to do their duty – even during times of terrible self-doubt, and inner conflict,” he said, noting that it was not his place to judge the dead of La Cambe “into whose conscience only God can see.”
Last year, when Ratzinger became the Vatican’s first German pontiff in several centuries, there was much talk about “God’s Rottweiler,” the “Panzer Cardinal” and Ratzinger’s brief stint as a German soldier and a Hitler Youth. Since then, the sniping has ceased. Benedict XVI has shown himself to be a pontiff who embraces the global community of Roman Catholics, transcending national identity and political borders with his eloquence, intelligence and compassion. He set the tone for his papacy earlier this year with the opening words of his first encyclical letter: “God is love, and he who abides in love abides in God, and God abides in him”
Later this month, however, when Benedict XVI returns to Auschwitz, a quarter century after his last visit, he will arrive not only as the leader of the world’s one billion Roman Catholics, but also as the most prominent moral spokesman for 80 million Germans. It will be an opportunity rich in symbolic and moral potential: a former Hitler Youth passing through the gates of a former Nazi death camp as one of the world’s leading spiritual authorities.
One hopes that Benedict will use this moment the way, for example, that Chancellor Willy Brandt did in 1970 when he fell to his knees, speechless with remorse, before the monument to the Warsaw Ghetto uprising, or the way President Richard von Weizsacker did in 1985 when he marked the 40th anniversary of the end of World War II with a landmark speech about the Germans’ collective responsibility to their past. “All of us, whether guilty or innocent, whether young or old, must accept the past,” Weizsacker said. “We are all affected by its consequences and are liable for it.”
Let’s hope Benedict XVI brings his full moral authority, his eloquence and his insight, to help us better understand the historical and moral responsibilities of the German people 60 years after the Holocaust. If he was able to speak as a German to the dead Waffen SS soldiers in La Cambe two years ago, let’s hope he can do the same for Germany’s victims at Auschwitz this spring.
(Timothy W. Ryback codirects the Institute for Historical Justice and Reconciliation at the Salzburg Seminar.)
ITALY: HOLOCAUST CARTOON STIRS ROW
Italy: Holocaust cartoon stirs row
Anti-Semitic caricature published by Italian Communist Party shows separation fence with welcome sign paraphrasing Auschwitz’s ‘Work Liberates’
By Yossi Bar
Yediot Ahronot
May 14, 2006
www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3250556,00.html
An anti-Semitic cartoon which appeared Friday in Liberzione, the journal of the Italian Communist Party, stirred a row among Italian Jews, the Israeli Embassy and parliament members.
The journal of the Rifondazione Communista party, set to be part of the coalition that will form the Italian government, published an anti-Semitic caricature showing the separation fence with a gate bearing the sign “Hunger Liberates,” similar to the welcome sign at the entrance to the Auschwitz extermination camp, which read “Work Liberates.”
Yasha Reibman, spokesman of Milan’s Jewish community, told Yediot Ahronot that the cartoon publication was a very severe act and demanded that the newspaper editor be dismissed immediately in a bid to prove that the stances presented by the journal do not represent the stances of the party it represents.
Israeli Ambassador to Rome Ehud Gol said in response that the anti-Semitic cartoon was shameful and humiliating and that he plans to respond to it harshly.
Parliament members from the democratic Left in Italy also slammed the cartoon.
However, Italian Lower Chamber Speaker Fausto Bertinotti, leader of the Communist party, as well as other party members, did not apologize and failed to even respond to the cartoon publication.
NAZIS “SHIPPED ARMS TO PALESTINIANS”
Nazis ‘shipped arms to Palestinians’
British National Archives unveil presence of Nazi S.S. agents in Mandatory Palestine, working closely with Palestinian leaders
By Yaakov Lappin
Yediot Ahronot
May 7, 2006
www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3248081,00.html
Historical documents in Britain’s National Archives in London show that Nazi Germany attempted to ship arms to Palestinian forces in the 1930s.
A British Foreign Office report from 1939 reports of “news of a consignment of arms from Germany, sent via Turkey and addressed to Ibn Saud (king of Saudi Arabia), but really intended for the Palestine insurgents.” Britain’s chief military officer in Mandatory Palestine also noted reports “regarding import of German arms at intervals for some years now.”
British documents from the same period, and German records photographed by an American spy and sent to the British government, said that a number of Nazi agents were sent to Mandatory Palestine, in order to forge alliances with Palestinian leaders, and urge them to reject a partition of the land between the Jewish and Arab populations.
One Nazi agent, Adam Vollhardt, arrived in Palestine in July 1938, and was reported to have gained strong influence with Arab leaders, meeting with Palestinian leaders throughout 1938. Vollhardt held several meetings with leading Arab politicians and told them “that the Palestine question would be settled to the satisfaction of the Arabs within a few weeks,” adding that “it would be fatal to their (Palestinians’) cause if at this juncture they showed any signs of weakness or exhaustion.”
“Germany was interested in the settlement of the (Palestine) question on the basis of the Arabs obtaining their full demands,” Vollhardt was reported to say to Palestinian leaders, according to a report by the British War Office. Vollhardt also assured Arab leaders that “the Germans could continue to support the Palestinian Arab cause by means of propaganda.”
German documents photographed and sent to Whitehall by an American spy revealed that in 1937, German officials had calculated that “Palestine under Arab rule would… become one of the few countries where we could count on a strong sympathy for the new Germany.”
‘Arabs admire our Fuhrer’
“The Palestinian Arabs show on all levels a great sympathy for the new Germany and its Fuhrer, a sympathy whose value is particularly high as it is based on a purely ideological foundation,” a Nazi official in Palestine wrote in a letter to Berlin in 1937. He added: “Most important for the sympathies which Arabs now feel towards Germany is their admiration for our Fuhrer, especially during the unrests, I often had an opportunity to see how far these sympathies extend. When faced with a dangerous behaviour of an Arab mass, when one said that one was German, this was already generally a free pass.”
A second Nazi agent, Dr. Franz Reichart, was reported to be actively working with Palestinian Arabs by the British Criminal Investigation Division “to help coordinate Arab and German propaganda.” Reichart was also head of the German Telegraphic Agency in Jerusalem.
German records show that the Nazis viewed the establishment of a Jewish state with great concern. A 1937 report from German General Consulate in Palestine said: “The formation of a Jewish state… is not in Germany’s interest because a (Jewish) Palestinian state would create additional national power bases for international Jewry such as for example the Vatican State for political Catholicism or Moscow for the Communists. Therefore, there is a German interest in strengthening the Arabs as a counter weight against such possible power growth of the Jews.”
Jewish refugees abandoned
The records also show that the news of increased Nazi-Arab cooperation panicked the British government, and caused it to cancel a plan in 1938 to bring to Palestine 20,000 German Jewish refugees, half of them children, facing danger from the Nazis.
Documents show that after deciding that the move would upset Arab opinion, Britain decided to abandon the Jewish refugees to their fate.
“His Majesty’s Government asked His Majesty’s Representatives in Cairo, Baghdad and Jeddah whether so far as they could judge, feelings in Egypt, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia against the admission of, say 5,000 Jewish children for adoption… would be so strong as to lead to a refusal to send representatives to the London discussions. All three replies were strongly against the proposal, which was not proceeded with,” a Foreign Office report said.
“If war were to break out, no trouble that the Jews could occasion us, in Palestine or elsewhere, could weigh for a moment against the importance of winning Muslim opinion to our side,” Britain’s Minister for Coordination of Defence, Lord Chatfield, told the British cabinet in 1939, shortly before Britain reversed its decision to partition its mandate, promising instead all of the land to the Palestinian Arabs.
BBC TO MAKE NAZI TRIAL EPIC ON 60TH ANNIVERSARY OF NUREMBERG
BBC to make Nazi trial epic
By Leigh Holmwood
The Guardian
May 8, 2006
The BBC is to mark the 60th anniversary of the trial of Nazi leaders at Nuremberg by screening an “epic” docudrama series telling the behind-the-scenes story.
The Nuremberg Trial – Inside the Nazi Mind, which will be made in partnership with Discovery, will be based on trial transcripts and new sources unearthed by the production team.
Executive producer John Farren said the series, which will air on BBC2 later in the year, had been “thoroughly researched” and would provide “gripping” television.
“This will be a dialogue-driven and actor-led drama documentary series,” he said.
Series producer Detlef Siebert said: “This series offers a unique chance to delve into the minds of the Nazi leadership.
“Rather than relying on the trial transcripts alone, we have unearthed a large number of other sources, which uncover what was going on behind the scenes of the trial.
“We can show what top Nazis like Goering, Speer or Hess revealed during their interrogations or in confidential conversations with psychologists or their co-defendants.”
The docudrama will be the BBC’s major historical series this year and follows previous landmark programmes such as last year’s six-part history of the Auschwitz concentration camp and Nazis – a Warning from History.
“HOLOCOST” RAP DUO CONQUERS PARIS
‘Holocost’ rap duo conquers Paris
New Parisian rap duo chooses particularly provocative name; black and yellow posters reading ‘Holocost’ in large print pasted around city advertise album release. Rappers - African and Cambodian immigrants – say: Our people undergoing holocaust too
By Sefi Hendler
Yediot Ahronot
May 15, 2006
www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3250983,00.html
A French rap duo calling themselves “Holocost” caused a stir in Paris recently after they pasted promotional posters up around the city announcing the release of their new album. The black posters with the word “Holocost” printed in yellow and an image of an automatic weapon were seen throughout the French city and its suburbs.
The rap album, called “L’Argent de la Brinks,” was produced by the record label Ghetto Fabulous, which represents independent artists. The two artists behind Holocost are Shone, an immigrant to France from Burkina Faso, and KER, of Cambodian origin. Both the rappers are from Clichy/Montfermeil outside Paris, near the suburb of Clichy-sous-Bois where the race riots began last autumn.
On their website, the two explain why they chose the provocative name. “When we created ‘Holocost’…we wanted to find a name that makes you ask, why are they called that? There is a certain provocation, but it is to attract interest. ‘Holocost’ means to say the extermination of a race, agreed? We consider slavery as a manner of exterminating a race. We appropriated the term because we were also subjected to a holocaust, and there isn’t a separate expression for that.”
The lyrics of Holocost’s songs do not have an anti-Semitic bent, but rather express severe social criticism directed chiefly towards French society. In one of their songs they sings, “When the police come to my ghetto, it’s an Intifada, Palestine.”
The album, which was released in mid-April, was well received in the rap community according to reviews in online rap websites and blogs.
“The place of rap in suburban culture is extremely important,” Jewish French author Michael Saban, who writes about the subject, said Sunday. “It started as a copy of the American model and turned into the most significant voice today among residents of French suburbs. There is consistent attention to police, violence, prisons and immigrant’s problems.”
According to Saban, the name chosen by the rappers is not surprising. “It’s a phenomenon that has existed for a while in France, a sort of ‘contest’ of suffering and memory. You might say that they want their own holocaust, that it also be recognized.”
Saban noted that the suburban rap scene has also seen anti-Semitic songs in the past. “There was a rap song called ‘Screw the Jews’ a year or two ago. There was an investigation launched, but the clip was anonymous and no band took responsibility for it,” Saban said.
Prominent figures in the Jewish community in Paris said that they have no intention of protesting the musical group. “Why should we give them free publicity?” they explained.
“MORE THAN 3000 MOUNTAIN JEWS WERE KILLED BY ARMENIANS DURING 1918-1919”
“More than 3000 Mountain Jews were killed by Armenians during 1918-1919”
By Rovshan Mustafayev
Today. AZ
April 21, 2006
www.today.az/news/politics/25410.html
Day.Az presents exclusive interview with Rovshan Mustafayev, the Director of the Human Rights Institute of the National Academy of Science.
– Mr Mustafayev, the facts of Jews’ genocide committed by Armenians in Guba region were announced today within a framework of round table organized by you. Tell our readers what was the point of origin for such researches?
– Recently the representatives of Mountain Jews community appealed to our Institute and told us about tragic events which took place during 1918-1919 in Guba city. According to them during those years there were mass killings of Mountain Jews committed by Armenian bandits.
Semen Ikhiilov, Head of Mountain Jews’ community, writes to the Human Rights Institute of the National Academy of Science: “In 1980s I discovered unknown facts regarding to mass killings of Jews during the period of Azerbaijanis’ genocide in 1918-1919. According to the witnesses and some documents, together with Azerbaijanis more than 3000 Jews were killed. For the moment we identified 87 names. Each year on March 31st, on the day of Azerbaijanis’ genocide of 1918-1919, special requiem prayers for 87 killed Jewish children, women and men are being read in the synagogues. We continue the researches of other places of mass burial in the regions of our Motherland, Azerbaijan. This letter is accompanied with the list of victims, who were killed by monsters on 19th Iyar, 5679, in Guba city,” the letter says.
Moreover, you can find in archives facts that during those times the Jewish problem was presented as the Tat problem, without a national identity. That’s why it was a problem of genocide committed by Armenians against the Tat ethnic group of Azerbaijan.
After we received the message from Jewish community the experts group was created for working with archives. We discovered this mass killings were committed by group headed by Amazasp under Stepan Shaumian’s command.
All the materials were collected by scintillas. But even though the information content is not so wide we can still receive faithful image of murderous deeds committed by Armenians against Mountain Jews, Lezghins, Azerbaijanis during those years in Guba.
– But what was a reason of killing Mountain Jews by Armenians?
– Jews just rejected proposal to join the Dashnak’s brigade against the Muslim population and tried to prevent a bloodshed. But Jewish envoy was brutally killed by the Amazasp’s brigade and the mass killings were started.
– How many persons killed by Armenians thugs were identified?
– For the moment we were able to identify 87 names. Moreover, we have numerous reports from Mountain Jews about their relatives being killed by Armenians and we are working on them.
There will be a statue erected by Mountain Jews in memory of the victims and the names will be written there. That’s why the complete identification is needed.
– And how those killings of Mountain Jews were committed by Armenians?
– How? And how the mass killings were committed during the Holocaust, in Babiy Yar, Hojaly, Hatyn...? Recently we received a letter from the Azerbaijan’s Georgian Jews Community offering their help in restoring historical truth.
CONTENTS
1. Important stories from Amsterdam, Boston, Pakistan and Riyadh
2. “The Netherlands & much of Europe prefer a traditional Muslim woman who keeps her mouth shut”
3. Saudi schoolbooks still contain messages “to fight the Jews”
4. Osama bin Laden warns those who would “interfere with [Saudi] school curricula”
5. “Dutch Courage” (Wall Street Journal Europe, May 21, 2006)
6. “This is a Saudi textbook” (Washington Post, May 21, 2006)
7. “Muslim reformer still a target” (Boston Globe, May 17, 2006)
8. “Rescued – the Pakistan children seized by Islamist slave traders” (Sunday Times of London, May 21, 2006)
IMPORTANT STORIES FROM AMSTERDAM, BOSTON, PAKISTAN AND RIYADH
[Note by Tom Gross]
This dispatch contains four significant and interesting stories about radical Islam and its spread across the globe. With the exception of the third piece, from the Washington Post about unchanged Saudi schoolbooks, they are unconnected to the Israeli-Palestinian dispute.
I attach these pieces because finally at least some articles are appearing in mainstream western media about the true cause of Islamic terrorism: radical Islam. (Most media, such as the BBC and The NY Times-owned International Herald Tribune continue on an almost daily to sell the lie that “western colonialism” or “poverty” are to blame.)
I believe it is a positive development that yesterday the (London) Sunday Times ran a piece about young Pakistani Christian children seized by Islamist slave traders. Buried among highly exaggerated reports of a supposed “humanitarian crisis” and “starvation” in the Gaza strip, at least one major mainstream media publication has finally run a report on the slave trade of Christian and other children. (Slavery is still widespread in several Muslim countries, not that you would know that if you only read the main headlines on CNN, The New York Times, and so on.) The depressing, shocking Sunday Times piece about children aged six to 12, is placed last below, because of its length.
“THE NETHERLANDS & MUCH OF EUROPE PREFER A TRADITIONAL MUSLIM WOMAN WHO KEEPS HER MOUTH SHUT”
Before that is an excellent editorial by Daniel Schwammenthal, a long-time subscriber to this email list, in The Wall Street Journal. (It was published in the U.S. on Saturday and in the Wall Street Journal Europe today.)
The Dutch treatment of Ayaan Hirsi Ali, who has been living for years with death threats for her criticisms of radical Islam, including a five-page manifesto titled “Open Letter to Hirsi Ali” which was pinned to Theo Van Gogh’s chest by his murderer, should serve as a warning to us all.